Don’t Bank On It: A Small Bank With Outsized CRE Risk
Our next highlighted bank is a publicly listed US community bank with roughly $2B in assets. On the surface, it looks reasonably well capitalized and remains profitable. However, its balance sheet is extraordinarily concentrated in real estate, while asset quality has deteriorated sharply despite the still relatively benign credit environment.
Please also take specific note that this is a good reminder that there are many weak lenders among community banks. So, while many may believe that community banks may be safer options, this a good example that they are not necessarily any better than larger banks.
Extremely high exposure to risky real estate lending
Commercial and agricultural real estate, multifamily and construction loans together amount to roughly 80% of the entire loan book. More importantly, these loans amount to roughly 650% of the bank’s CET1 capital. Multifamily alone represents almost 20% of the loan book, while CRE accounts for more than half. Despite this already massive concentration, loan growth during the latest quarter was again driven by CRE and multifamily lending.
Asset quality is deteriorating very rapidly
Nonperforming loans have almost doubled over the past year and are now above 2.2%. What is important is that the deterioration is concentrated exactly where the bank has its largest exposure: CRE and multifamily lending. In addition, other categories of problem loans, such as substandard and criticized loans, have also doubled.
Loan-loss reserves are currently even below the NPL level. This is very concerning for a bank whose risky real estate loans amount to roughly 650% of its CET1 capital.
Problem loans are highly concentrated
Another concern is that the bank’s problem loans are highly concentrated. Roughly 70% of special-mention and substandard loans are tied to just 10 relationships. As such, the bank does not need a broad credit crisis for just a few relationships to create a meaningful hit.
Capital may come under pressure if deterioration continues
The bank remains well capitalized today, with CET1 of roughly 11.4% at the holding company and 13.3% at the bank. However, criticized loans alone now amount to as much as 35% of the bank’s CET1 capital and NPLs to 18%. Given the bank’s massive real estate concentration and relatively thin reserve coverage, even a mild further deterioration in credit quality could put pressure on capital.
Can you recognize this bank?
